Music Australia News

Federal Government links alternative music to violent extremism

Jasmine Crittenden
| September 29, 2015

A Federal Government booklet aimed at preventing radicalisation has provoked public anger for its perceived linking of alternative music and left-wing activism with violent extremism. Michael Keenan, the Minister Assisting the Prime Minister on Terrorism, launched the “Radicalisation Awareness Information Kit” on 21 September, encouraging its use in schools.

A chapter titled “Violent Extremism” contains a case study about a fictitious character named Karen. Having “grown up in a loving family who never participated in activism of any sort”, she moves out of home to attend university, where she becomes “involved in the alternative music scene, student politics and left-wing activism”. She then develops a passion for environmental protest, moving into a forest camp and taking part in illegal activities, such as barricading, spiking trees and sabotaging machinery, leading to numerous arrests for “trespass, damaging property, assault and obstructing police”.

Jonathan La Nauze, a campaigner at the Australian Conservation Foundation, told the ABC, “It sounds like something that’s been dreamt up in the cigar room of the Institute of Public Affairs … To link standing up for the places that we love, standing up for the future of our children, to violence and extremism and terrorism, does nothing to combat a real threat to the safety of people or to respect the very peaceful and very meaningful protests that people engage in from all walks of life to ensure that we have a safe future in this country.”

Meanwhile, Maurie Mulheron, president of the New South Wales Teachers’ Federation, described the kit as “a fairly cynical move by the Federal Government, not to make anyone feel safer, but to engender fear and intolerance.”

The International Association for the Study of Popular Music – Australian and New Zealand (IASPM-ANZ) released an official statement, calling on the Government to “withdraw these materials from schools.” The statement reads, “Our organisation strongly objects to the linking of participation in the alternative music scene to radicalisation of any kind. There is no reputable evidence to suggest that listening to certain types of music leads to particular political outcomes for the audience. Suggesting that young people who listen to certain types of music are in some way more ‘dangerous’ than others is not only insupportable, but can have negative consequences for those young people.”

The case study inspired ridicule on social media, with critics using the hashtag #freekaren to draw attention to their commentary. On 25 September, barrister and human rights activist Julian Burnside tweeted, “It’s heavy-handed government propaganda like that which radicalizes people. Done under Abbott I guess. #FreeKaren”. On the same day, journalist Wendy Harmer tweeted a photo of children on Collaroy Beach holding a “Save Our Beach” sign, accompanied by the quip, “Raising a terrorist cell here in Collaroy”.

Friends of the Earth Australia has established a petition, calling on the Prime Minister to withdraw the Radicalisation Awareness Information Kit.



  1. Phillip Patrick

    This article is reactionary. It is not so much the “alternative music” that is the subject but is more just context and setting. In the case study about Jay, he seeks advice from two older men about all sorts of aspects of his life including whether or not to get married. Should the scouts or any other similar Father-Son social groups be up in arms based on what they think is being insinuated here.

  2. Steven Rea

    As a musician, educator and father to two small children, I object to the association made between terrorism and the arts, environmentalism and social activism. I strive to engender a strong sense of social justice in my children and my students, and to imply that these are in any way akin to terrorism is offensive, and the exact opposite of the political and religious fundamentalism that breeds so much of the terror this “kit” seeks to assuage.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Stay in the loop

Music Australia updates straight to your inbox

Follow Like
Quick Links


  • National clearing house for policy & development

  • Music Journal

    Features articles about the Music Industry Sector

  • Music Talks

    Series of seminars exploring music